Federalism essays

Federalism essays

Essay on Federalism Essay on Federalism. Federalism Federalism is a widely accepted system of government in North American cultures. To Disadvantages Of Federalism. Federalism is a type of government where the power is divided between  · $ for a 2-page paper In this essay I am going to explain Wheare’s definition of federalism, provide some criticism to it, and try to apply it to federal states. Wheare’s definition is a principle by which governmental powers are divided so that the general and regional governments are each, within a sphere, co-ordinate and blogger.comted Reading Time: 8 mins Federalism, one of the most important principles incorporated in the Constitution of this nation, is a political system in which the power is shared between the national and state governments. Not only does this system help limit the powers of the national government as a whole, it also helps increase the power of the state governments which is crucial in

Federalism Essay Examples - Free Research Papers on blogger.com

Federalism essays is clear when we look at the globe that many countries are too large for all the administration to come from the capital. The process of de-centralization distributing the functions of the government is, therefore, federalism essays, a more agreeable option.

There are various forms of de-centralization. The most important of these forms of de-centralization, however, is that of federalism, where legal sovereignty is shared between central and regional governments.

In my opinion this definition is relatively vague, but Wheare accepts that many students will not accept his definition. I am going to outline his arriving at this decision. Wheare gives a loose meaning of the term federalism. He then goes on to say that these theorists differ when it comes to the question of the form of association that a federal system should have. Wheare decides to take the Constitution of the United States of America as his example.

He maintains that it has become so that any definition of federalism which does not mention this Constitution is not adequate despite the fact that he states that the US Constitution does not mention federalism essays words federal or federation at all, federalism essays.

In federalism essays case the central government is independent on certain matters, and the state governments are independent on other matters. The citizen, federalism essays, therefore, is federalism essays directly to two governments. These governments, federalism essays, however, are not subordinate, but co-ordinate with each other.

It was only through amendments to the original Constitution that it got to be this way. The old Constitution saw the government as an agent and the state government dependent on the central government; now they have equal positions. He comes to the conclusion that each federal government is different to the next, but that it universally thought that the United States is the prime example of a federal state.

Of course, it is very difficult to define federalism. It is given that it is a Constitutional concept where authority is geographically divided, and the US Constitution is taken as a model. There is naturally the problem of the difference between what is laid down on paper and what actually happens.

Perhaps it is the idea of federalism which is flawed. Blondel analyzes the definition that Wheare gives federalism essays. Blondel cited five of his federal features.

In the first one of these he asks how we are to allocate the functions of governments to their respective levels; the division of the fields of governmental activity. He wonders about the number and relationship between the authorities; how many levels federalism essays government should there be, and how should they be related to each other.

Where should we locate the power to federalism essays and select authorities? He then asks where should the administrative and implementing areas of the government be. In the last of his federal features, Blondel asks the critical question: Where is the location of constitutional power going to rest? Who is going to provide the answers to all the questions? If constitutional power rests on one government, the other government is dependent on that government, federalism essays.

Therefore these powers have to be shared, federalism essays. Blondel comes to the conclusion that Wheare defined federalism in a constitutional way, and not in relation to practice. There federalism essays a major ambiguity in the concept of federalism in that there is an overlap of sub-national and unitary states. An example of this is comparing unitary Britain with federal Germany, federalism essays. In Britain, local government is administrative.

In Germany the administration is carried out by the central government. How much de-centralization or centralization does a country need to be defined as a federal state? In a unitary state there is no limit to centralization, and in a federation there is no limit to de-centralization. But even in countries such as Britain there federalism essays been significant moves towards de-centralization. European and American federalism both have different roots and ideals. In Europe, especially in Germany there is a sense of federalism essays over the co-operation between the levels of government.

The federation links the people of the different regional states together, federalism essays. In Europe there is a conscious effort to make the decisions at the lowest level possible, allowing the central government to offer a presiding leadership overall.

Each has a constitution, which must be in keeping with the republican, democratic and social principles set out in the federal constitution, the Basic Federalism essays. Germany is on of the classic federal states, and has had a long run of federalism, broken only by the National Socialist unitary state of Germany has realized that it is much easier for a country with a federal structure than a centralized state to take account of regional characteristics and problems.

A federal structure is good for countries with regional diversities, as Germany and the US have, as it promotes regional culture. The Basic Law has determined the law-making powers of the states and the federal government. They have been grouped into three categories: exclusive, concurrent and framework legislation. The Federation may only legislate in such cases that it is necessary to have a uniform law for the whole country.

In general administration the Federation is limited to the administration of foreign affairs, federalism essays, the armed forces, and taxation. Most administrative responsibilities lie with the states themselves. The federalism essays of the states lies in their participation federalism essays legislation through the Bundesrat.

Thus Germany has become a country in which most laws are enacted centrally federalism essays the bulk of legislation is administered by the member states. The Basic Law for the Federal Republic was adopted inand was not intended as a definitive constitution, only as a temporary framework for a new democratic system. Its authors wanted to make sure that the disasters of the previous constitution, which led to the Nazi domination of Germany, were not repeated, federalism essays.

The Basic Law became a solid framework, and its requirement for reunification was fulfilled in Germany is a federal state based on the rule of law and social justice. It opted for indirect representative democracy. Public authority must be recognized and approved of by the people, but they have no direct say in the exercise of that authority, except in elections.

The constitutional decision is in favour of a federal state, federalism essays. The sixteen Lander have some of the federalism essays of a state, as does the central federal government. Each state has its own powers which are restricted to certain spheres. At the centre of the Basic Law is the concept of the rule of law, and this incorporates the separation of powers, federalism essays.

The executive, legislature, federalism essays, and judiciary exercise public authority, and are independent to each other. This is also mirrored in the system of checks and balances that exists in Germany as it does in the US. In my research I have realized that the Federal Republic of Germany and the United States of America are very similar in practice. This Constitution was drawn up in by the Founding Fathers, to replace the weak confederation that had existed since the Declaration of Independence.

The vastness and diversity of the different states federalism essays a federal constitution. Of course, anti-federalists claim that the Founding Fathers created a national government in this constitution. The US Constitution is a particularly ambiguous one, as it can be interpreted in many different ways, federalism essays. Different groups have used the same Article to argue separate points; many claim it to be irrelevant in modern America. In the American Constitution the federal government has been granted autonomy from the state federalism essays, but this is checked with the powerful state influence in Congress, federalism essays.

In my federalism essays of the situation the central government is very powerful, due to the extended interpretation over the years of Article 1, federalism essays. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite. As I have said before, there is often huge difference in what happens in practice than what was set out in the written Constitution, federalism essays.

Federalism essays US Constitution is a guide, and not a blueprint. The Swiss Constitution has many unique features, which owe themselves to the origin of the Republic.

This led to the League of Thirteen Members and lasted for three centuries. In independence was granted by the Treaty of Westphalia. In the French occupation brought about a constitution moulded on the French. In the Congress of Vienna recognized the independence of the Swiss Confederation, and a new federal Constitution was adopted in which was replaced by the Constitution of The actual system of government in Switzerland is quite different to that of the US or of Germany, federalism essays.

The supreme legislative authority, like the other two countries we have discussed, is the Federal Assembly which is divided into two chambers: the National Council, federalism essays, which is elected by the population, federalism essays, and the Council of States, which consists of two members per state. Three federalism essays the cantons states are divided into two because of old tradition.

This produces a strange situation in the Council of States, since they only have half a vote, and hence only one seat. It results in the canton of Basle city a half canton withinhabitants has one vote, and the canton of Uri, federalism essays, with only The Federalism essays Assembly consists of seven members, and they jointly govern the country.

They take it in turn to become the chair, and thus the President of the Confederation. There can be no vote of censure, and neither the parliamentary vote nor referendum can cause the Council to resign. Two strange features of Swiss government are those of referendum and initiative.

The people can, if they produce a petition bearing the signatures ofpeople, federalism essays, demand that the Constitution be totally or partially revised, federalism essays.

The cantons in Switzerland represent the states in the United States of America. These are sovereign in federalism essays far as the sovereign rights are not limited by the Federal Constitution. In some of the small cantons direct democracy still exists. The citizens assemble in the capital and can take part in the discussion. In some cantons laws must be brought to the people before they are implemented. I have discussed the federalism essays aspects of federalism federalism essays relation to three countries, but how do these countries, and others, relate to the definition of federalism given by K.

In his definition, Wheare did not specify which powers were to be allocated to each government, both state and federal. This is a problem that I have with this definition.

The Constitution, the Articles, and Federalism: Crash Course US History #8

, time: 13:04

Federalism Research Paper - Free Essay Example | blogger.com

 · 1) Federalism provides a division of legal authority between state and national governments. Overlap occurs, but two legally distinct spheres of government exist. 2) The states are subordinate to the national government in such areas as management of foreign affairs and regulation of interstate commerce  · Federalism is a system that is embedded into the politics of the USA; federalism involves the sharing of powers between the different levels of government: the State governments and the Federal government. Federalism is a significant factor in the USA, but it does not even exist in some countries; for example, the United Kingdom has a unitary system where all  · $ for a 2-page paper In this essay I am going to explain Wheare’s definition of federalism, provide some criticism to it, and try to apply it to federal states. Wheare’s definition is a principle by which governmental powers are divided so that the general and regional governments are each, within a sphere, co-ordinate and blogger.comted Reading Time: 8 mins